Wednesday: Using Skepticism to Stop Fraud Before It Starts
Protecting the public interest means doing our work with integrity and care. Every state employee plays a role in protecting public resources. One of the most helpful habits we can develop is professional skepticism. Although the term is often associated with auditors or investigators, it is a valuable skill for each of us.
Today’s Daily Content will discuss how professional skepticism can help to protect our state resources, what it is, why it matters and key behaviors we can all put into practice to keep fraud at bay.
What is Professional Skepticism and Why Does it Matter?
Professional skepticism is about asking questions, verifying information, and being alert to anything that doesn’t seem quite right. Simply put, professional skepticism is having a questioning and curious mindset, and not just assuming things are working effectively. Without having a questioning and curious mindset, things like errors and fraud may go unnoticed. Professional skepticism helps:
- Spot red flags
- Prevent problems before they escalate
- Improve the quality of our work
- Lead to better decisions and more accurate results in our day-to-day tasks
How Do I Build This Skill?
Professional skepticism is like a muscle; it gets stronger with use. You can strengthen this skill by:
- Staying curious. Keep asking why and how.
- Learning the roles and responsibilities assigned to you: become a subject-matter “wizard”
- Recognizing red flags early. Be aware of signs that may indicate a problem exists, such as:
- Incomplete or inconsistent documentation
- Sudden vendor changes, such as address, bank information or invoice patterns
- Requests to bypass normal processes or controls
- Questionable or altered documentation
- Verifying instead of assuming. Cross-check purchase orders, invoices and approvals. Confirm explanations with supporting documents. Review any complex or unusual transactions with extra care.
- Asking good questions. When something appears off, use simple but direct questions. “Do we have documentation that supports this change?” “Can you walk me through this transaction?” “Has this been reviewed and approved according to policy?”
- Applying controls every time. Internal controls work when consistently followed. Use proper approval hierarchies, keep separation of duties intact, be sure to document reviews and decisions. If you have concerns, report them promptly. Skipping controls, even for the smallest of tasks, creates risk.
- Checking for bias. Don’t assume long-time employees or vendors are always correct. Treat familiar and unfamiliar situations with the same care. Avoid rushing through tasks because they ‘seem routine.’
- Seeking other perspectives and welcoming opposing ideas. Ask for help when things are complex or unfamiliar to you.
- Slowing down, especially for key processes in your work.
- Talking things through. Don’t tackle complex issues alone. Discuss the concern with your supervisor and use formal reporting channels, when needed. It is better to ask questions earlier than to investigate problems later.
- Noticing when something “doesn’t add up,” such as a transaction, explanation or a behavior that seems unusual - pause and review the details.
- Creating a culture where employees can raise concerns. Encourage each other to ask questions, request documentation and voice concerns without fear of negative consequences.
Professional skepticism requires awareness, practice, and ongoing learning. It helps us improve the quality of our work, protect the public interest, and strengthen integrity and trust in state government. Let’s help protect our organization by using this skill to make sure financial transactions, documentation, and decisions are reviewed carefully and objectively. It takes all of us to be fraud aware and build a culture that supports transparency and empowers us, together, to stop fraud. Each and every one of us.
Resources
Review these resources for more information on professional skepticism and creating a fraud-aware culture.