A former Minnesota insurance broker has been charged with fraud after an investigation by the Minnesota Commerce Fraud Bureau found evidence he invented customers and faked Social Security numbers to earn nearly $650,000 in improper commissions. 

The charges, filed this month in Ramsey County District Court, allege that Kevin Anthony Meyers, 48, submitted hundreds of policy applications from fictitious customers while working for Cigna Corp. from 2018 to 2020. Under the terms of his employment, Meyers was eligible for commissions even before customers paid premiums. The Commerce Fraud Bureau investigation found that 401 life insurance policies he claimed to have sold from May 2018 to June 2019 never generated a premium payment to Cigna. Some of the Social Security numbers on the policies did not exist or belonged to people who had died. 

The charges say Meyers used the fraudulent commission payments to buy cars, airline tickets, and for shopping. His bank records show he paid $76,000 to a Jaguar Land Rover dealer and withdrew more than $100,000 in cash. Under terms of a civil consent order filed by Commerce in March, Meyers must repay $648,000 to Cigna within five years. The Department of Commerce, which licenses insurance brokers in Minnesota, revoked his insurance license retroactively and imposed a civil penalty of $100,000, which will be waived when he repays Cigna. 

“Commerce’s mission is to protect the interests of Minnesotans and to ensure a fair and equitable marketplace in our state,” said Jacqueline Olson, Assistant Commissioner for Enforcement at the Commerce Department. “That includes thoroughly investigating any allegations of insurance fraud, which harms both consumers and businesses. I’m proud of the work the Commerce Fraud Bureau did on this case.” 

Some of his supposed customers told investigators they knew Meyers but had not purchased insurance from him. Meyers, whose office was in Vadnais Heights, also earned commissions after reporting sales to employees of a company called Synergy Benefits Solutions. Investigators determined that Meyers was the sole owner of Synergy. 

“We are grateful for the hard work of the Minnesota Department of Commerce fraud investigators to bring this case forward to our office,” Ramsey County Attorney John Choi said. “The burden of this type of fraud is shouldered by the public through increases in insurance rates, and the law enforcement focus on uncovering this type of financial fraud is our priority.” 

The charges against Meyers include six felony counts of fraud, theft by swindle and identity theft. The most serious counts carry a sentence of up to 20 years in prison and a fine of $100,000. Meyers’ first appearance in Ramsey County District Court is set for Oct. 10. 

If you have questions, concerns, or complaints about insurance, contact the Minnesota Department of Commerce Consumer Services Center at consumer.protection@state.mn.us or 651-239-1600 or 800-657-3602. 

Get updates and news from the Minnesota Department of Commerce by following Commerce on Facebook and Twitter or by subscribing to our news email list.  

MEDIA CONTACTS: 

Brett Benson
Minnesota Department of Commerce
brett.benson@state.mn.us