Real Estate Appraisal Advisory Board

The Real Estate Appraisal Advisory Board was re-established in 2019. This seven-member board is charged with advising, providing input, and suggesting best practices to the Commerce Department regarding real estate appraisers and the appraisal industry generally.

The board provides this input on several topics, including, but not limited to, licensing, public disciplinary matters, continuing education, and industry-related trends.

Board meetings are accessible and open to the public.

Upcoming Meeting

September 16, 2026
10:00 AM – 12:00 PM

Via Microsoft Teams
Meeting ID: 259 485 858 853 516
Passcode: mn3dT6PR
Call In (audio only)
+1 651-395-7448, Phone Conference ID: 954 952 273#
Join Microsoft Teams Meeting

If you want to attend in person, it will be held at:

Summit Conference Room
Minnesota Department of Commerce
85 7th Place E
St. Paul, MN 55101

September 16, 2026
If any documents do not meet your accessibility needs, please submit an accessibility request.

Watch the Meeting [YouTube]

Agenda (.pdf)

Appraiser License Upgrades, September 11, 2026 (.pdf)

Continuing Education Courses — Second Quarter 2026 (.pdf)

Current Appraiser and AMC Statistics, September 11, 2026 (.pdf)

Enforcement Actions, September 14, 2026 (.pdf)
- Altman, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Haug, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Hosfield, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Lexvold, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Ovick, Consent Order (.pdf)
June 4, 2026
Watch the Meeting [YouTube]

Agenda [pdf]
Minutes [pdf]
- Continuing Education Courses — First Quarter 2026 [pdf]
- Appraiser Demographic Data [pdf]
- Consent Order, Ann Elizabeth Nasset [pdf]
- Consent Order, John James Hadtrath [pdf]
- Consent Order, Dominic John Talarico [pdf]
- Active Licenses [pdf]
- Appraiser License Upgrades [pdf]
- Enforcement Actions [pdf]
- National Uniform Licensing and Certification Examination Pass Rates [pdf]
- Appraiser Licensing Exam Pass Rates [pdf]
February 10, 2026
Watch Meeting

Agenda [pdf]
- Approved meeting minutes for December 15, 2025 meeting [pdf]
- Appraiser License Upgrades January 30, 2026 [pdf]
- Appraiser and AMC Statistics [pdf]
- Memo, CE Courses, Fourth Quarter, 2025 [pdf]
- Notice to Commissioner - draft [pdf]
- Enforcement Actions [pdf]
- Androsky [pdf]
December 15, 2025
Enforcement Actions November 2025 [pdf]

Approved meeting minutes, September 17, 2025 (.pdf)
- Briggs, Consent Order [pdf]
- Carey, Consent Order [pdf]
- Gramm, Consent Order [pdf]
- Oseland, Consent Order [pdf]
- Spaeth, Consent Order [pdf]
- Steinbach, Consent Order [pdf]
- December 15, 2025 meeting video (.mp4)
September 17, 2025
Watch Meeting

Agenda, September 17, 2025 Meeting [.pdf]

Approved Meeting Minutes, May 8, 2025 [.pdf]

Memo, CE Courses, Second Quarter, August 21, 2025 [pdf]

Appraiser License Upgrades, August 21 2025 [pdf]

Appraiser and AMC Statistics [pdf]

Enforcement Actions August 2025 [pdf]
- Hraba, Consent Order [pdf]
- Larson, Consent Order [pdf]
- Reverts, Consent Order [pdf]
- Wicker, Consent Order [pdf]
May 8, 2025
Watch Meeting

Agenda, May 8, 2025 Meeting (.pdf)

Approved Meeting Minutes, February 18, 2025 (.pdf)

Memo, CE Courses, First Quarter, April 18, 2025 [pdf]

Appraiser License Upgrades, April 2025 [pdf]

Appraiser and AMC Statistics [pdf]

National Licensing Examination Pass Rates (.pdf)

Minnesota Appraiser Licensing Examination Pass Rates (.pdf)

Enforcement Action April 15, 2025 [pdf]
- McCleary, Consent Order [pdf]
February 18, 2025
Watch Meeting

Agenda, February 18, 2025 Meeting [pdf]

Approved Meeting Minutes, December 13, 2024 [pdf]

Memo, CE Courses, Fourth Quarter, February 6, 2025 [pdf]

Appraiser License Upgrades, February 2025 [pdf]

Appraiser and AMC Statistics [pdf]

Enforcement Action February 3, 2025 [pdf]
- Ekstrum, Consent Order [pdf]
- Koons, Consent Order [pdf]
- Nesseth, Consent Order [pdf]
- Struss, Consent Order [pdf]
December 13, 2024
Meeting Agenda, December 13, 2024 [pdf]

Approved Meeting Minutes, September 18, 2024 [docx]

Memo, CE Courses, Third Quarter, December 3, 2024 [pdf]

Appraiser License Upgrades, December 2024 [pdf]

Appraiser and AMC Statistics [pdf]

Enforcement Actions, November 27, 2024 [pdf]
- Henderson, Consent Order [pdf]
- LaTourelle, Consent Order [pdf]
- Nasset, Consent Order [pdf]
- Struss, Consent Order [pdf]
September 18, 2024
Watch Meeting

Meeting Agenda, September 18, 2024 (.pdf)

Meeting Minutes, May 10, 2024 (.pdf)

Memo, CE Courses, Second Quarter, September 6, 2024 (.pdf)

Appraiser License Upgrades, September 2024 (.pdf)

Appraiser and AMC Statistics (.pdf)

Enforcement Actions, February 2024 (.pdf)
- Haeg, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Heyblom, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Miller, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Trana, Consent Order (.pdf)
May 10, 2024
Watch Meeting

Meeting Agenda, May 10, 2024 (.pdf)

PAREA Presentation (.pptx)

Agenda and Minutes, February 13, 2024 (.pdf)

Memo, CE Courses, First Quarter, May 3, 2024 (.pdf)

Appraiser License Upgrades, January 2024 (.pdf)

Appraiser and AMC Statistics (.pdf)

Enforcement Actions, February 2024 (.pdf)
- Carlsten, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Jacobson, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Perrella, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Runberg, Consent Order (.pdf)
February 13, 2024
Watch Meeting

Meeting Agenda, February 13, 2024 (.pdf)

Agenda and Minutes, December 7, 2023 (.pdf)

Memo, CE Courses, Fourth Quarter, January 29, 2024 (.pdf)

Appraiser License Upgrades, January 2024 (.pdf)

Appraiser and AMC Statistics (.pdf)

Enforcement Actions, February 2024 (.pdf)
- Wheeler-Knopf, Consent Order (.pdf)
December 7, 2023
Watch Meeting

Agenda, December 7 (.pdf)

Slides, December 7 (.pptx)

Minutes, September 27, 2023 (.pdf)

Memo, CE Courses, November 27, 2023 (.pdf)

Active Licensees, November 27, 2023 (.pdf)

License Upgrades, November 2023 (.pdf)

Enforcement Actions, December 2023 (.pdf)
- Burns (.pdf)
- Hilla (.pdf)
- Litchke (.pdf)
- Pronold (.pdf)
- Thomsen (.pdf)
September 27, 2023
Watch Meeting

Agenda, September 27, 2023 (.pdf)

Minutes, June 9, 2023 (.pdf)

Memo, CE Courses, September 15, 2023 (.pdf)

Appraiser License Upgrades, September 15, 2023 (.pdf)

Appraiser and AMC Statistics (.pdf)

Non-State Employee Expense Form (.pdf)

Enforcement Actions, September 11, 2023 (.pdf)
- Bauman, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Broback Consent Order (.pdf)
- Johanneck, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Kollender, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Peterson, Consent Order (.pdf)
June 9, 2023
Watch Meeting

Agenda, June 9, 2023 (.pdf)

Minutes, June 9, 2023 (.pdf)

Memo, CE Courses, May 26, 2023 (.pdf)

Appraiser License Upgrades, May 30, 2023 (.pdf)

Enforcement Actions, May 25, 2023 (.pdf)
- Baucom, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Fisher, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Gottschalk, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Haug, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Hennen, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Herzog, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Klein, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Krueger, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Olson, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Sonnee, Consent Order (.pdf)
February 28, 2023
Watch Meeting

Agenda, February 28, 2023 (.pdf)

Minutes, October 6, 2022 (.pdf)

Memo, CE Courses, February 10,2023 (.pdf)

Appraiser License Upgrades, February 13, 2023 (.pdf)

Enforcement Actions, February 13, 2023 (.pdf)
- Bloomquist, Consent Order (.pdf)
- JA Weber, Consent Order (.pdf)
- JM Weber, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Isaak, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Neuhring, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Jungers, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Griffith, Consent Order (.pdf)
October 6, 2022
July 14, 2022
April 14, 2022

Watch the meeting

Agenda, April 14, 2022 (.pdf)

Minutes, January 20, 2022 (.pdf)

Memo, CE Courses, March 25, 2022 (.pdf)

Appraiser and AMC Statistics, September 13, 2021 (.pdf)

Active Licensees, March 25, 2022 (.pdf)

Enforcement Actions, March 28, 2022 (.pdf)

Buss, Consent Order (.pdf)

Heffernan, Consent Order (.pdf)

Kloha, Consent Order (.pdf)
January 20, 2022
Agenda, January 20, 2022 (.pdf)

Minutes, December 21, 2021 (.pdf)

Memo, CE Courses, January 6, 2022 (.pdf)

Active Licensees, January 6, 2022 (.pdf)

Enforcement Actions, January 7, 2022 (.pdf)
- McCleary, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Aho, Consent Order (.pdf)
December 2, 2021
Agenda, December 2, 2021 (.pdf)

Memo, CE Courses, November 17, 2021 (.pdf)

Active Licensees, November 17, 2021 (.pdf)

Enforcement Actions, November 16, 2021 (.pdf)

Practical Applications of Real Estate Appraisal (PAREA) (.pdf)
- Bianchi, Civil Penalty and Agreement (.pdf)
- Fingerhut, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Frank, Consent Order (.pdf)
- Hammerschmidt, Consent Order (.pdf)
September 23, 2021
Agenda, September 23, 2021 (.pdf)

Minutes, April 1, 2021 (.pdf)

Memo, CE Courses, September 13, 2021 (.pdf)

Appraiser and AMC Statistics, September 13, 2021 (.pdf)

The Appraisal Foundation Final Results, Diversity Survey (.pdf)

Enforcement Actions, September 7, 2021 (.pdf)
- Consent Order, Gordon Collin (.pdf)
- Consent Order, Alan Gottschalk (.pdf)
- Consent Order, Donna Jacobson (.pdf)
- Consent Order, Steven Zimmerman (.pdf)
April 1, 2021
January 21, 2021
Agenda, January 21, 2021 (.pdf)

Meeting Minutes, January 21, 2021 (.pdf)

Draft Minutes REAA Board Meeting, December 10, 2020 (.pdf)

Active Licensees, January 6, 2021 (.pdf)

Licensing Report, January 6, 2021 (.pdf)

Enforcement Actions, January 8, 2021 (.pdf)
- Consent Order, Michael J. Becker (.pdf)
- Civil Penalty and Agreement, Jerrod A. Gates (.pdf)
Actions and Recommendations from the Advisory Board Workgroup (.pdf)

Practical Applications of Real Estate Overview (.pdf)
December 10, 2020
Minutes (.pdf)

Agenda December 10, 2020 (.pdf)

Draft Minutes REAA Board Meeting, September 10, 2020 (.pdf)

Licensing Report, November 25, 2020 (.pdf)

Enforcement Memo November (.pdf)
- Consent Order, Keller (.pdf)
- Consent Order, Adseiji (.pdf)
Licensing Statistics November 25, 2020 (.pdf)
September 10, 2020
Minutes (.pdf)

Agenda September 10, 2020 (.pdf)

Draft Minutes REAA Board Meeting, June 23, 2020 (.pdf)

Licensing Report for September Meeting (.pdf)

Enforcement Memo September (.pdf)
- Consent Order, Kruse (.pdf)
- Consent Order, Perrella (.pdf)
Licensing Statistics August 28, 2020 (.pdf)

Letter to TAF August 20, 2020 (.pdf)

Black Homeowners Face Discrimination in Appraisals, NY Times August 25, 2020 (.pdf)
June 23, 2020
January 16, 2020
November 7, 2019
August 14, 2019
June 4, 2019
March 29, 2019
February 14, 2019
October 31, 2018