City of Bloomington & Bloomington Police Officers Federation     

Arbitrator Jeffrey W. Jacobs        

Issue: Veterans Preference Termination 

Military veteran police officer terminated after causing damage to gas pump. City alleged was not forthcoming in admitting how damage occurred, and at risk of being placed on Brady-Giglio list.              

Grievance Sustained in Part        Veteran returned to work after serving 60-day unpaid suspension. Officer immediately reported pump was broken, and admitted to throwing the handle in the investigation. While violation of multiple policies justifies lesser discipline, no evidence that he lied under Garrity.

"> City of Bloomington & Bloomington Police Officers Federation     

Arbitrator Jeffrey W. Jacobs        

Issue: Veterans Preference Termination 

Military veteran police officer terminated after causing damage to gas pump. City alleged was not forthcoming in admitting how damage occurred, and at risk of being placed on Brady-Giglio list.              

Grievance Sustained in Part        Veteran returned to work after serving 60-day unpaid suspension. Officer immediately reported pump was broken, and admitted to throwing the handle in the investigation. While violation of multiple policies justifies lesser discipline, no evidence that he lied under Garrity.

"> skip to content

Arbitration Award Summaries

Brief overviews of arbitration awards submitted to the Bureau.
BMS Case No. 26VP0409 - City of Bloomington

City of Bloomington & Bloomington Police Officers Federation     

Arbitrator Jeffrey W. Jacobs        

Issue: Veterans Preference Termination 

Military veteran police officer terminated after causing damage to gas pump. City alleged was not forthcoming in admitting how damage occurred, and at risk of being placed on Brady-Giglio list.              

Grievance Sustained in Part        Veteran returned to work after serving 60-day unpaid suspension. Officer immediately reported pump was broken, and admitted to throwing the handle in the investigation. While violation of multiple policies justifies lesser discipline, no evidence that he lied under Garrity.

Last Modified: 4/24/2026 Size: 0 Author: Categories: Tags:
back to top