Line 3 Pipeline Replacement
Project Docket Details
Docket No | PPL-15-137 |
Project name | Line 3 Pipeline Replacement |
Applicant | Enbridge, LLP |
Description | Enbridge Energy proposes to replace 337 miles of the Line 3 Pipeline in Minnesota. Line 3 originates in Canada, continues through North Dakota, enters Minnesota in Kittson County, and terminates in Superior, Wiscsonsin. |
Location | Aitkin County, Carlton County, Cass County, Clearwater County, Crow Wing County, Hubbard County, Kittson County, Marshall County, Pennington County, Polk County, Red Lake County, Wadena County |
Contact | Sam Weaver sam.weaver@state.mn.us (651) 539-1531 |
Status |
View All...
|
Project Summary
Enbridge Energy (Enbridge) proposed to construct a new oil pipeline in Minnesota to replace its existing Line 3 pipeline. Enbridge stated that the purpose of the project is to address pipeline integrity and safety concerns related to the existing Line 3 and to restore the throughput of the line to its original operating capacity of 760,000 barrels per day (bpd).
Enbridge applied for a certificate of need (CN) and a route permit from the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission (Commission) in April 2015. The Minnesota Department of Commerce, in cooperation with the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources and the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, prepared an environmental impact statement (EIS) for the project. The final EIS was issued in February 2018. Following public hearings and a report from an administrative law judge, the Commission issued a certificate of need and a route permit for the project in the fall of 2018.
In June 2019, the Minnesota Court of Appeals found the final EIS for the project to be inadequate. The Deparment of Commerce subsequently revised the final EIS. On May 1, 2020, the Commission found the final EIS adequate and reissued the certificate of need and route permit for the project. On December 1, 2020, Enbridge started construction of the project. Enbridge anticipates that it will take 6 to 9 months to construct the project.
Latest News
- Court of Appeals Confirms Commission Decisions Regarding Adequacy of the Second Revised Final EIS, and the Certificate of Need and Route Permit for the Line 3 Project. June 14, 2021.
- Commission Approves Compliance Filings; Enbridge Begins Construction of the Line 3 Project. December 1, 2020.
- Parties Challenge Second Revised Final EIS, Certificate of Need, and Route Permit at Minnesota Court of Appeals -- Red Lake Band, White Earth Band, Honor the Earth, and Sierra Club; Youth Climate Intervenors; Mille Lacs Band of Ojibwe; Friends of the Headwaters; Department of Commerce. August 20, 2020
- Commission Issues Order Finding Second Revised Final EIS Adequate and Reissuing a Certificate of Need and Route Permit for the Line 3 Project, May 1, 2020
- The Department of Commerce has Issued the Second Revised Final EIS for the Line 3 Project. Comments on the Adequacy of the EIS Will be Accepted by the Commission through January 16, 2020. December 9, 2019
- Commission Issues Order Finding Final EIS Inadequate and Requesting Department of Commerce to Revise the EIS to Include Analsyis of a Potential Oil Spill Into the Lake Superior Watershed, October 8, 2019
- The Minnesota Supreme Court Declines to Review Challenges to the EIS for the Line 3 Project, September 17, 2019
- The Minnesota Court of Appeals Finds the EIS for the Line 3 Project Inadequate and Remands the Matter to the Commission for Further Proceedings, June 3, 2019.
- Commission Issues Order Approving Certificate of Need Modifications for the Line 3 Project, January 23, 2019
- Commission Issues Order Granting a Pipeline Routing Permit for the Line 3 Project, October 26, 2018
- Commission Issues Order Granting a Certificate of Need for the Line 3 Project With Modifications and Requiring Additional Filings, September 5, 2018
- Parties Challenge Adequacy of Line 3 Final EIS at Minnesota Court of Appeals - Friends of the Headwaters, Honor the Earth, Chippewa and Ojibwe Bands, August 13, 2018
- Commission Issues Certificate of Need and Route Permit for the Line 3 Project. The Commission's Written Order is Pending, June 28, 2018
- Commission Sets Oral Argument, Deliberation, and Public Attendance Procedures for Line 3 Certificate of Need and Route Permit Decisions, June 8, 2018
- Commission Issues Notice of Comment Period for the Revised Final EIS for the Line 3 Project. Written Comments Accepted Through 4:30 p.m., February 27, 2018, February 12, 2018
- Final EIS - Revised Issued by Department of Commerce, February 12, 2018
- Briefing Schedule Adjusted to Facilitate ALJ Report by April 23, 2018 (Fourth Post-Hearing Order), January 11, 2018
- Briefing Schedule Extended to Accommodate Supplementing of Final EIS, December 22, 2017
- Commission Identifies Deficiencies in the Final EIS for the Line 3 Project and Requests Department of Commerce to Submit Additional Information, December 13, 2017
- Schedule for Proposed Findings, Briefing, and Report (First Post-Hearing Order) Set by Administrative Law Judge Ann C. O'Reilly, November 22, 2017
- Administrative Law Judge Eric Lipman Recommends that the Commission Find the Final EIS for Line 3 Project to be Adequate, November 1, 2017
- Evidentiary Hearing Schedule and Logistics (Eighth Prehearing Order) Issued by Administrative Law Judge Ann C. O'Reilly, October 31, 2017
- Department of Commerce Issues Press Release on its Direct Testimony for the Line 3 Project, September 11, 2017
- Commission Issues Notice of Public and Evidentiary Hearings for the Line 3 Project. Written Comments Accepted Through 4:30 p.m., November 22, 2017, September 8, 2017
- New Hearing Schedule (Amended Fifth Prehearing Order) Issued by Administrative Law Judge Ann C. O'Reilly, August 29, 2017
- Commission Issues Notice of Public Comment Period on Final EIS. Comments Accepted Through 4:30 p.m., October 2, 2017 August 23, 2017
- Public Comments Received on the Line 3 Draft EIS Posted on eDockets and the Department of Commerce's Line 3 Website, August 2, 2017
- New Hearing Schedule (Fourth Prehearing Order) Issued by Administrative Law Judge Ann C. O'Reilly, May 31, 2017
- Draft EIS for Line 3 Project Available for Public Review and Comment. Comments Accepted Through July 10, 2017 May 15, 2017
- Enbridge Files Direct Testimony in Support of its Certificate of Need and Route Permit Applications, January 31, 2017
- Notice of EIS Preparation for the Line 3 Pipeline Replacement Project , December 5, 2016
- Final Scoping Decision for the Line 3 EIS Issued by Commerce EERA , December 5, 2016
- Commission Issues Order Approving a Scoping Decision for the Line 3 EIS , November 30, 2016
- Hearing Schedule Issued by Administrative Law Judge Ann C. O'Reilly, October 28, 2016
This map depicts the pipeline alternatives being evaluated in the environmental impact statement for the Line 3 project. Users can move to different parts of the map by clicking and dragging the cursor to a new location. Users can zoom in and out using the scroll wheel of their mouse or by clicking on the plus or minus buttons is the viewer toolbox.
The map includes several data layers depicting resources that could be impacted by the project. These data layers can be turned on and off by clicking the box next the data layer name. The data layers extend for 10 miles on either side of an alternative. Some layers are visible at a small map scale (zoomed out). Other map layers are only visible at a large map scale (zoomed in). If you click to view a data layer and do not see the layer depicted, zoom in or out until it appears.
Key Project Documents
Date | Title | Description |
---|---|---|
09/08/2022 | Existing Line 3 Landowner Choice Program | The Landowner Choice Program allows landowners along the existing Line 3 pipeline to choose either pipeline removal or decommissioning in place. EERA staff serves as an independent liaison to ensure that program requirements are met, and landowners have access to an independent engineer at the company's expense. |
05/01/2020 | Commission Order Finding Second, Revised Final EIS Adequate and Reissuing a Certificate of Need and Route Permit for the Line 3 Project | The Commission's order finding the second, revised final environmental impact statement (EIS) adequate and reissuing a certificate of need and route permit for the Line 3 project. Includes Commission order and reissued orders from 2018 and 2019. |
12/09/2019 | Final Environmental Impact Statement for the Line 3 Pipeline Project - Second Revision | The second revised final environmental impact statement (EIS) for the Line 3 pipeline project. This second revision addresses the Commission's order to analyze a potential oil spill from the pipeline into the Lake Superior watershed. |
10/08/2019 | Commission Order Requesting Revision of Final EIS | Commission order finding the final EIS inadequate and requesting the Department of Commerce to revise the EIS to include analysis of a potential oil spill into the Lake Superior watershed. |
01/23/2019 | Commission Order Approving Modifications to Certificate of Need for the Line 3 Project | The Commission's order approving modifications to the certificate of need for the Line 3 project. The order addresses five modifications: parental guaranty, landowner choice program for pipeline removal, decommissioning trust fund, neutral footprint program, and liability insurance. |
10/26/2018 | Commission Order Granting a Pipeline Routing Permit for the Line 3 Project | The Commission's order granting a pipeline routing permit for the Line 3 project. Includes order, routing permit, and maps. |
09/05/2018 | Comission Order Granting a Certificate of Need for the LIne 3 Project with Modifications and Requiring Additional Filings | The Commission's order granting a certificate of need for the Line 3 project. The order requires additional filings which must be approved by the Commission. |
02/12/2018 | Final Environmental Impact Statement for the Line 3 Pipeline Project - Revised | The revised final EIS for the Line 3 pipeline project issued by the Deparment of Commerce |
04/24/2015 | Certificate of Need Application -- Line 3 Pipeline Replacement Project | Enbridge Energy is proposing to construct a new 337-mile long oil pipeline to replace an existing pipeline, Line 3, in Minnesota |
04/23/2015 | Route Permit Application -- Line 3 Pipeline Replacement Project | Enbridge Energy proposes to replace 337 miles of existing Line 3 Pipeline and associated facilities between the Norht Dakota/Minnesota border and the Minnesota/Wisconsin border. |
Environmental Review and Permitting Process
Enbridge's proposed Line 3 replacement project requires two approvals from the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission (Commission) - a certificate of need (CN) and a route permit. Enbridge applied to the Commission for these approvals in April 2015.
The Minnesota Environmental Policy Act (MEPA) requires that an environmental impact statement (EIS) be prepared for major governmental actions that have the potential for creating significant environmental impacts. To fulfill its MEPA responsibilities, the Commission has authorized the preparation of an EIS that addresses Enbridge's CN and route permit applications. The Commission has authorized Commerce's Energy Environmental Review and Analysis (EERA) staff to prepare the EIS, in cooperation with the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources and the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency.
The EIS will be issued in draft form, a draft EIS, so that it can be improved through public comment. A final EIS will be developed based on comments received on the draft EIS. Upon completion of the final EIS, public hearings will be held in the project area. The hearings will be presided over by an administrative law judge (ALJ) from the Office of Administrative Hearings. The hearings will address Enbridge's CN and route permit applications. At the public hearings, citizens will have an opportunity to submit comments, present evidence, and ask questions. After completion of the hearings, the ALJ will submit a report to the Commission with findings of facts, conclusions of law, and recommendations regarding a CN and route permit for the project. Decisions by the Commission on Enbridge's CN and route permit applications are anticipated in the spring of 2018. Click here for an environmental review and permitting flowchart.
Questions Asked and Answered
During the environmental review and hearing processes for the Line 3 project, the Department of Commerce and other agencies may receive questions from citizens, local governments, and tribes about the project. Twice a month we'll summarize here the questions that we've received and the answers that we've provided. Hopefully, these questions and answers will be helpful to all persons participating in the state's environmental review and hearing processes for the Line 3 project.
If you have a question about the Line 3 project or the state's environmental review and hearing processes for the Line 3 project, please contact us. Scroll down to the "Participate" section on this webpage and you'll find phone and email contacts for Department of Commerce and Commission staff.
- January 9, 2017. Topics: maps; schedule; viewing testimony
- January 23, 2017. Topics: SA-04; changes in oil blends; the social cost of carbon
- February 6, 2017. Topics: decommissioning in-place of existing Line 3; Canadian National Energy Board report
- February 20, 2017. Topics: U.S. State Department draft supplemental EIS for Line 67
- April 10, 2017. Topics: Draft EIS issuance date; participating in public hearings
- May 30, 2017. Topics: Draft EIS at libraries; public meeting format; Draft EIS comments
- June 26, 2017. Topics: Availability of Draft EIS comments
- September 12, 2017. Topics: Final EIS and Public Hearing Comment Periods
Participate
Sign up for the project mailing list to receive notices about project milestones and opportunities to participate (meetings, comment periods, etc.). Contact docketing.puc@state.mn.us, 651-201-2204 , or 1-800-657-3782 with the project's docket number(s), your name, mailing address, and email address. The Line 3 project has two docket numbers. The docket number for Enbridge's certificate of need application is 14-916. The docket number for Enbridge's route permit application is 15-137.
To review all documents filed with the Commission regarding the Line 3 project, go to: http://www.mn.gov/puc/, click on "Search Documents, eDockets," and enter the docket number. The Line 3 project has two docket numbers. The docket number for Enbridge's certificate of need application is 14-916. The docket number for Enbridge's route permit application is 15-137.
To receive an email every time a document is filed with the Commission regarding the Line 3 project, create a subscription with the Commission's electronic docketing system (eDockets). Go to: https://www.edockets.state.mn.us/EFiling/subscription/createSubscription.do?method=subscribeNew and follow the instructions.
If you have questions or need more information please contact:
Minnesota Department of Commerce (Environmental Review)
- Andrew Levi, andrew.levi@state.mn.us, 651-539-1840 or 1-800-657-3794
- Ray Kirsch, raymond.kirsch@state.mn.us, 651-539-1841 or 1-800-657-3794
Minnesota Public Utilities Commission (Permitting and Commission Process)
- Scott Ek, scott.ek@state.mn.us or 651-201-2255
Enbridge Energy (Line 3 Project)
- enbridgeinmn@enbridge.com, 1-855-788-7805